Based in Burlington. Helping business owners in Oakville, Milton, Mississauga & Hamilton.

289 339-8100info@lgfinancial.ca

Blog · Critical Illness

Critical Illness Return of Premium: How the Refund Works

Return of premium critical illness insurance can pay back your premiums if you never make a claim. When the refund is paid, and how much comes back, is set by each policy.

Woman at a table writing in a notebook with her phone beside her
Key points
  • Return of premium is an option on some critical illness policies. It can pay back premiums if no critical illness benefit is paid.
  • The CLHIA lists three times a refund may be paid: if you cancel, when the policy ends at a set age, or if you die.
  • If you cancel, you may get back only part of your premiums. The share usually depends on how long you kept the policy.
  • In a shared ownership plan, your company owns the illness coverage and you own the refund.
  • The CRA has not issued a formal ruling on how the refund is taxed in a shared ownership plan.

How does return of premium critical illness insurance work?

With critical illness insurance, return of premium is an option. It can give back premiums if you never get a critical illness benefit. Some policies build it in. On others, you buy it as an extra.

First, the base cover. Critical illness insurance pays a lump sum if you are diagnosed with a serious illness the policy covers. Examples are cancer, a heart attack or a stroke. That is how the Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) describes it. Canadian life and health insurers work together through this group.

The refund part sits on top of that cover. The CLHIA guide says your policy explains how the refund is worked out. It also says these options may only be in individual policies, not in group plans.

Think of it as insurance first. The illness cover is the reason to buy. The refund only matters if you never need that cover.

When is the refund paid?

It depends on the policy. The CLHIA lists three times a refund may be paid. Each policy sets its own rules. Timing differs from one insurer to the next.

WhenWhat may come backWhat to check in the policy
You cancel the policyA share of the premiums you paid. The share usually depends on how long you kept it.How many years before any refund, and what share at each point
The policy ends at a set ageA refund at that age, if you never qualified for a full claimThe age the cover ends, such as 65 or 75
You die while the policy is in forceThe premiums you paid, to your estate or, in some provinces, to a person you nameWho receives the refund

The CLHIA adds a tip that applies to all of these. Stopping your premium payments does not earn you a refund.

What happens to the refund if you make a claim?

Generally, once a full critical illness benefit is paid, there is no refund. The CLHIA says return of premium options may not apply after a critical illness benefit has been paid.

Some policies also pay a partial benefit for less severe conditions, such as some early cancers. The CLHIA says the policy does not end after a partial payment. The amount may come off the full lump sum.

How a partial payment affects the refund is set by the policy wording. It is worth asking before you buy.

How does the refund work in a shared ownership plan?

Two owners share one policy. Your company owns the illness coverage, and you own the refund.

  • Your company pays the bigger part of the cost. If you get sick and the claim is approved, the company gets the lump sum.
  • You pay the smaller part, for the refund. If you never claim, the refund comes to you. It can include the premiums your company paid.
  • A written agreement says who owns what. A lawyer writes it, and your accountant checks it.

Fair shares matter here. The Income Tax Act has a rule for this. If a company gives a shareholder a benefit, its value is generally added to that person's income. That is why each side pays for its own part.

Our critical illness insurance page shows this plan step by step, with an example. Why would a company want the lump sum? Our post on what happens to your business if you get sick covers that.

Is the refund taxed?

This is the open question. The plan is designed for the refund to reach you tax-free, and our page describes it that way. But the CRA has not issued a formal ruling on how the refund is taxed in a shared ownership plan.

So the point is not settled in writing. The CLHIA calls the critical illness lump sum itself non-taxable. The refund is a separate question, because it can include premiums your company paid.

Two more points matter. If your company pays the lump sum out to you, that money is generally taxed in your hands. And on December 4, 2025, the CRA warned about certain schemes. They use borrowed money to buy critical illness insurance in a company, often from an offshore insurer. The CRA says they are designed to let shareholders take money from their company without paying tax.

The warning is about schemes built on loans. It does not mention return of premium or shared ownership. Still, ask your accountant to review the agreement and the tax side before you count on a tax-free refund.

Who is return of premium not a fit for?

Critical illness insurance with return of premium is not for everyone. Here are the honest trade-offs:

  • You must qualify on health. An insurer can say no, or leave out a condition.
  • The refund needs time. If you cancel early, you may get back only part of the premiums.
  • The premiums are a real cost every year, and stopping them does not earn a refund.
  • If you claim, the refund is generally gone. That is the trade for getting the lump sum.
  • A group plan, through work or an association, may not offer this option.
  • The tax point in a shared ownership plan is not settled.
  • It is insurance, not an investment. The refund gives back premiums. It is not investment growth.

What can you ask before choosing a refund option?

Start with the policy wording. These questions cover most of it:

  • When is the refund paid: at a set age, after a number of years, or both?
  • What share comes back if the policy is cancelled early?
  • Does a partial payment change the refund?
  • Who receives the refund if I die?
  • In a shared ownership plan, who owns which part, and what does each side pay?

Then take the answers to your accountant. We can show how a plan would work for your company. We share the numbers with them to review. If your company has more cash than it needs, our homepage explains the bigger picture.

Sources

This information is general in nature and is not tax, legal, accounting, insurance or investment advice. It is based on current Canadian tax legislation, which can change. Any strategy should be designed and reviewed with your accountant and legal advisors based on your circumstances. Tax rates are approximate and reflect current Ontario and federal rules.

Want to see when the refund would be paid in your plan?

A short call covers when the refund is paid, who pays which part, and what to take to your accountant.

Or call us now: 289 339-8100

Thank you! We will call you soon.