Disability Insurance for Physicians vs Critical Illness: What Doctors Should Know
Disability insurance for physicians pays a monthly benefit while illness or injury keeps you from working. Critical illness insurance pays one lump sum if you are diagnosed with a condition the policy covers and meet its terms, whether or not you can still work.
- If you bill OHIP fee-for-service, you are paid for the insured services you provide, so billing stops when you stop working.
- Disability insurance pays a monthly benefit while you cannot work, generally after a waiting period.
- Critical illness insurance pays one lump sum for a covered diagnosis that meets the policy's terms. Your ability to work is not part of the claim.
- Disability benefits can be taxable or tax-free, depending on who pays the premium. The CLHIA describes the critical illness lump sum as non-taxable.
- The two pay for different events, so they can work side by side.
Why does disability insurance matter to a doctor?
Because your income depends on your ability to work. Under Ontario's Health Insurance Act, OHIP pays a doctor for the insured services that doctor provides and bills. If you bill fee-for-service and stop seeing patients, there is nothing to bill.
The Act also lets the Minister of Health pay doctors on a basis other than fee for service. Doctors in some family practice groups, such as a Family Health Organization, are paid mainly through capitation. That is a regular payment linked to the patients enrolled with them. If that is you, ask your group how a long absence would affect your pay.
If a hospital or clinic pays you as an employee, it may have its own sick leave or disability plan. Check with your employer.
What does disability insurance for physicians pay?
It pays a monthly benefit that replaces part of your income while you cannot work. The Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) speaks for Canada's life and health insurers. It calls this an income replacement benefit.
The details in the policy decide what you get. These are the parts to read closely:
- Waiting period. Benefits start only after you have been disabled for a set time. The CLHIA guide gives 30, 90 and 180 days as examples.
- What "disabled" means. Some policies ask if you can do your regular occupation. Others ask if you can do any work that fits your education, training and experience. For a doctor with a narrow specialty, this wording matters a great deal.
- Partial benefits. Some plans pay based on lost income, not only on a full stop. That helps if you can still work, but for fewer hours or with different duties.
- How long it pays. Some plans pay for a set time, often two to five years. Others pay to age 65 while you stay disabled.
- Who owns the plan. An individual plan stays with you. With an association plan, premiums usually rise as you age, the CLHIA says. You may also need to show good health when it renews.
- Practice costs. The CLHIA says individual plans for self-employed people can be set up to cover business overhead costs and help with bank loans.
What does critical illness insurance pay?
It pays one lump sum if you are diagnosed with a covered condition and meet the policy's terms. The CLHIA describes the payment as non-taxable, so it is generally tax-free. How you use it is up to you.
You know medicine, so here is the catch. The CLHIA guide says a doctor's diagnosis alone does not make a claim payable. The policy's own terms must be met:
- The condition must match the policy's written definition, which can require a certain severity.
- The diagnosis generally must be made by a licensed physician who is a specialist in that condition.
- Some conditions require you to survive a set number of days after diagnosis.
- Some conditions, such as cancer, have an exclusion period after the policy starts. Signs, symptoms, tests or a diagnosis in that time can rule out a claim for that condition.
Is critical illness insurance the same as disability insurance?
No. One replaces income while you cannot work. The other pays a lump sum for a diagnosis. Here is critical illness vs disability insurance side by side, based on the CLHIA guides.
| Disability insurance | Critical illness insurance | |
|---|---|---|
| What starts a claim | Being unable to work, as the policy defines it | Diagnosis of a covered condition, as the policy defines it |
| How it pays | Monthly, after a waiting period | One lump sum |
| Does work matter? | Yes, it pays while you are off work | No, work is not part of the claim |
| Tax on the benefit | Taxable or tax-free, depending on who paid the premium | Described by the CLHIA as non-taxable |
| What it is for | Your monthly income | Any cost you choose |
Does it matter who pays the premium?
Yes, for disability insurance. Under the Income Tax Act, if an employer pays into a disability plan, the monthly benefits for lost pay from a job are generally taxable. Any amount you paid in yourself is taken off the taxable amount.
The CLHIA guide says that if you pay the full premium yourself, the benefits are generally tax-free. If your medical corporation pays the premium, ask your accountant how these rules apply to you.
For critical illness insurance, the corporation can be the owner. With shared ownership, your medical corporation owns the illness coverage and gets the lump sum. You own the return of premium part. If the corporation then pays the money out to you, that payment is taxed. Our page on critical illness insurance for doctors shows how it works.
Where does critical illness fit for an incorporated doctor?
It fills a different gap. Each plan leaves out something the other covers:
- Disability insurance generally pays nothing if you are diagnosed but keep working as before.
- Critical illness insurance does not replace a monthly income through a long disability.
- Critical illness insurance pays only for the conditions it lists. Some things can stop a doctor from working but are not on the CLHIA's list of typical covered conditions. Two examples are a back injury and depression.
If your medical corporation has more money than the practice needs, shared ownership lets the corporation pay most of the cost. For the bigger picture, see our 3 plans for extra money in a corporation. For EI and the CPP disability benefit, see our post on what happens when a business owner gets sick.
What are the trade-offs?
Neither plan suits everyone. Here are the honest trade-offs:
- Both need you to qualify on health. An insurer can say no, leave out a condition or charge more.
- Premiums are a real cost every year, whether you claim or not.
- A long waiting period on a disability plan leaves the first months unpaid.
- If a critical illness policy has a premium refund, making a claim can end it.
- Some doctors have enough savings to carry a long absence on their own.
What can I ask before I decide?
Whether you already hold physician disability insurance or are looking at it, start with these questions:
- How does the policy define disability, and does that change after a set time?
- How long is the waiting period, and how long do benefits last?
- Are the benefits taxable, given who pays the premium?
- Which conditions does the critical illness policy cover, and what are its survival and exclusion periods?
Your accountant leads the tax side. We complement them, and we share any numbers with them to review. You can also read more about us.
Sources
- CLHIA consumer guides: A Guide to Critical Illness Insurance (2024) and A Guide to Disability Insurance (Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association)
- CLHIA news release on its critical illness consumer guide, 2024
- Health Insurance Act, sections 2 and 17.1 (Ontario e-Laws)
- Income Tax Act, paragraph 6(1)(f), disability plan benefits (Justice Laws)
- Primary care payment models in Ontario (Government of Ontario)
Related guides
Critical Illness Insurance
How your corporation can own the illness coverage, and how the premiums can come back to you if you never claim.
Read the guideWhen a Business Owner Gets Sick
What EI and the CPP disability benefit do and do not pay when an owner cannot work.
Read the guideIf a Doctor Can't Work, Who Pays the Bills?
What happens to an Ontario doctor's income and practice costs during an illness, and where the money can come from.
Read the articleThis information is general in nature and is not tax, legal, accounting, insurance or investment advice. It is based on current Canadian tax legislation, which can change. Any strategy should be designed and reviewed with your accountant and legal advisors based on your circumstances. Tax rates are approximate and reflect current Ontario and federal rules.
Do you know what your coverage pays if you cannot work?
A short call covers how disability and critical illness coverage differ for a doctor, and what to ask your accountant.
Or call us now: 289 339-8100
Thank you! We will call you soon.
