Borrowing Against a Life Insurance Policy in Retirement: How the Loan Works
Borrowing against life insurance means you use the cash value of a permanent policy to get a loan, while the coverage stays in place. The loan has interest and lender limits. The tax result depends on who lends and who borrows.
- Borrowing against life insurance works only with permanent insurance that builds a cash value. Term insurance has no cash value to borrow against.
- A policy loan from the insurer counts as a disposition under the Income Tax Act. The part above the policy's adjusted cost basis is generally taxed as income.
- Pledging a policy to secure a bank loan is not a disposition. The pledge alone does not trigger tax on the policy.
- Interest, lender limits and collateral calls are real risks. The CLHIA says leveraging magnifies the risk.
- A loan left unpaid at death can reduce what your family or company receives.
Why do owners look at borrowing against life insurance?
It starts with a need for life insurance that lasts your whole life. The death benefit can pay debts, replace income or provide for a family. For an owner, it can also protect the company or a business partner.
Permanent life insurance usually builds a cash value. Term insurance does not. Whole life is one kind of permanent insurance. Its premiums do not change as you get older, and it often has a guaranteed minimum cash value.
Later in life, that cash value can back a loan, for example to add to retirement income. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) says this is possible. You may be able to take a policy loan, or use the policy as collateral for a loan. Collateral is something a lender can claim if a loan is not paid.
So the order matters. The insurance comes first, and the loan is a later option. It is not a way to get rich.
What are the ways to get money from a policy?
There are three common ways. A life insurance loan can come from the insurer or from a bank. Each way has a different result under the Income Tax Act.
| Way | Coverage | Tax under the Income Tax Act | Main catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cancel the policy (surrender) | Ends | Generally, the amount above the adjusted cost basis is taxed as income | The coverage is gone |
| Policy loan from the insurer | Stays | Counts as a disposition. Generally, the part above the adjusted cost basis is taxed as income | Interest, and an unpaid loan can lower the death benefit |
| Bank loan with the policy as collateral | Stays | Pledging the policy is not a disposition | Interest, lender limits and collateral calls |
The adjusted cost basis is, in plain words, the policy's cost for tax. Among other items, premiums paid add to it, and a yearly amount called the net cost of pure insurance takes it down. The insurer works out that amount under the tax rules.
How is a policy loan taxed?
The tax rules treat a policy loan as if you sold part of the policy. A policy loan is money the insurer advances under the terms of the policy. Generally, the part above the adjusted cost basis is added to the owner's income.
Over the years, the adjusted cost basis can go down. When it does, more of a new policy loan can be taxed. If part of the loan pays a premium right away, under the policy terms, that part is left out.
A policy has a cash value well above $50,000 and no other loans. The owner takes a $50,000 policy loan. The adjusted cost basis just before the loan is $20,000.
$50,000 minus $20,000 is $30,000. Generally, that $30,000 is taxable income for the policy owner that year. If a company owns the policy, the income is the company's.
These figures are not from a real client. Your own numbers will be different.
How does a bank loan against a policy work?
The policy owner pledges the policy to a lender as security. This is often called a collateral assignment. Under the Income Tax Act, assigning a policy to secure a loan is not a disposition. This rule does not cover a policy loan from the insurer.
So the pledge alone does not create tax on the policy's growth. The money from the lender is a debt that must be paid back, not income.
In a company plan, the details matter. The company owns the policy. Either the company borrows, or you borrow and the company's policy backs your loan.
- Who borrows changes the tax result. Your accountant checks the set-up before it starts.
- The Income Tax Act generally counts a benefit a company gives a shareholder as the shareholder's income. If the company's policy backs your personal loan, your accountant checks whether that rule applies.
- Say the company borrows and pledges its own policy, and stays the policyholder or beneficiary. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) says the net proceeds at death can still go to the company's capital dividend account. This holds even if the lender is paid directly.
Net proceeds generally means the death benefit minus the policy's adjusted cost basis. The company files an election to pay a capital dividend from that account. That dividend is generally tax-free to shareholders who live in Canada. Our Corporate Insured Retirement Program page shows how the plan fits together.
What are the risks of a loan against a policy?
The risks sit right beside the benefit. A plan that uses a loan backed by a policy is often called leveraged life insurance. Leverage means using borrowed money. The Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) has a guideline on illustrations. It says leveraging magnifies the risk.
That guideline asks insurers to describe these risks when an illustration shows a collateral loan:
- Interest. The loan rate may be higher than the rate the policy values assume. Interest that is added to the loan, not paid, makes the debt bigger.
- Lender limits. A lender limits the loan compared with the policy's cash value. The loan can grow past that limit.
- Collateral calls. The lender may ask for more security. This is called a collateral call. The lender may also call the loan, which means asking for it to be paid back sooner than planned.
- Living longer. If you live past the expected age, the loan has more years to grow.
Three more risks are worth knowing:
- Policy dividends are not guaranteed. If they are lower, the cash value can grow more slowly. That leaves less room under the lender's limit.
- Interest on money for living costs is generally not deductible. The Income Tax Act allows the deduction for money borrowed to earn business or investment income. Money spent on living costs does not qualify.
- Less at death. FCAC says a loan you do not repay may reduce what your beneficiary receives.
Who does this not fit?
Borrowing against a policy is not for everyone. Here are the honest limits:
- You have no lasting need for life insurance. The plan is built on coverage you would keep anyway.
- The company may need the money soon. Premiums tie money up for many years.
- You must qualify on health. An insurer can say no.
- You want a fixed, known income. The loan depends on values that are not guaranteed and on the lender's terms.
- A collateral call would be hard to meet from other savings.
What can I ask before I decide?
Start with your accountant. Here are questions to bring:
- What is the policy's adjusted cost basis today, and how could it change?
- Who would borrow, the company or me? What is the tax result of each?
- What does the less favourable scenario show? When values are not guaranteed, the CLHIA guideline expects at least two scenarios.
- What happens if interest rates rise or dividends fall?
- What does the loan agreement say about limits and collateral calls?
Your accountant leads the tax side. We complement them and share any numbers with them to review. Our life insurance page explains term, whole and universal life. Our post on what to do with retained earnings covers other choices for extra money in a company.
Sources
- Income Tax Act, section 148, including the definitions of policy loan, disposition and adjusted cost basis (Justice Laws)
- Income Tax Act, section 89, capital dividend account (Justice Laws)
- Income Tax Act, section 20, paragraph 20(1)(c), interest (Justice Laws)
- Income Tax Act, section 15, benefit conferred on a shareholder (Justice Laws)
- Income Tax Folio S3-F2-C1, Capital Dividends (Canada Revenue Agency)
- Income Tax Folio S3-F6-C1, Interest Deductibility (Canada Revenue Agency)
- Life insurance (Financial Consumer Agency of Canada)
- CLHIA Guideline G6, Illustrations (Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association)
Related guides
Corporate Insured Retirement Program
Life insurance your company owns, and how its cash value can back a loan in retirement.
Read the guideLife Insurance
Term, whole and universal life, and which kinds build a cash value.
Read the guideParticipating Whole Life Insurance: What Is and Is Not Guaranteed
What a participating whole life policy guarantees, what it does not, and when policy dividends are taxed.
Read the articleThis information is general in nature and is not tax, legal, accounting, insurance or investment advice. It is based on current Canadian tax legislation, which can change. Any strategy should be designed and reviewed with your accountant and legal advisors based on your circumstances. Tax rates are approximate and reflect current Ontario and federal rules.
Thinking about borrowing against a policy in retirement?
A short call covers how the loan would work, what happens if rates rise, and what to ask your accountant.
Or call us now: 289 339-8100
Thank you! We will call you soon.
