Based in Burlington. Helping business owners in Oakville, Milton, Mississauga & Hamilton.

289 339-8100info@lgfinancial.ca

Blog · Corporate Tax

Participating Whole Life Insurance: What Is and Is Not Guaranteed

Participating whole life insurance covers you for life and lets the policy owner share in the insurer's profits through policy dividends. Those dividends are not guaranteed. Your contract and illustration show which values are.

Printing calculator on a desk
Key points
  • Participating whole life insurance covers you for life. It can also pay policy dividends from the insurer's profits.
  • Policy dividends are not guaranteed. Under the federal Insurance Companies Act, the directors may declare them under the insurer's dividend policy.
  • An illustration should show which values are guaranteed. When some are not, it should show at least two scenarios.
  • A policy dividend is generally taxed only on the part above the policy's adjusted cost basis.
  • Growth left inside an exempt policy is not taxed each year. Its death benefit is generally paid tax-free.

What is participating whole life insurance?

It is life insurance for your whole life, with a share in the insurer's profits. The Income Tax Act calls it a participating life insurance policy when the owner can share in those profits. The shares are paid as policy dividends.

It is still insurance first. People buy it because someone will need money when they die. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada (FCAC) lists uses such as paying debts and replacing income. For an owner, it can also protect the company.

Insurers set up under the federal Insurance Companies Act must keep separate accounts for participating policies. That account gets its share of the insurer's investment income or losses. It also carries its share of expenses, including taxes.

What does a participating whole life policy guarantee?

The contract decides. The Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) has a guideline on illustrations. It gives a strict test. A value is guaranteed only if the insurer cannot change it on its own, and it does not depend on future results.

FCAC says whole life insurance covers you for your entire life, and your premiums do not change as you get older. The policy often has a guaranteed minimum cash value.

Part of the policyGuaranteed?Where to check
Coverage for lifeYes, as set in the contract, while the policy stays in forceThe contract
PremiumsSet in the contract, and they do not rise with ageThe contract
Minimum cash valueOftenThe guaranteed values in the illustration
Policy dividendsNoThe non-guaranteed values in the illustration
Future growth from dividendsNoThe less favourable scenario in the illustration

Why are whole life insurance dividends not guaranteed?

They depend on how the insurer's participating business does. The Insurance Companies Act says the directors may declare a dividend under the insurer's dividend policy. First, the actuary must report in writing on whether it is fair to participating policyholders.

An actuary is a specialist who uses math to measure long-term risks and costs. The law also requires the insurer to have a dividend policy before it sells participating policies.

The tax rules mention a dividend scale, which shows the dividends a policy is expected to pay. The exempt test assumes dividends will be paid as the scale shows. But a scale is not a promise. CLHIA's guideline says actual results may vary, up or down, from those illustrated. That holds for every scenario shown, including the less favourable one.

The word itself can confuse. CLHIA's guideline names "dividend" as a term that works differently in insurance than in other financial products. A policy dividend is not a share dividend from a company.

What can the owner do with policy dividends?

Each contract lists its own dividend options. The tax rules refer to these uses:

  • Take the dividend in cash.
  • Use it to pay a premium.
  • Use it to repay a policy loan.
  • Buy paid-up additions. These add extra coverage that is fully paid for. They count toward the cash value.

In a Corporate Insured Retirement Program, the company owns the policy. The dividend option affects how much cash value builds up. A lender may later lend against that cash value. So lower dividends can mean less room to borrow.

Are life insurance dividends taxable?

It depends on how the dividend is used and on the policy's adjusted cost basis. The tax rules treat a policy dividend as if the owner sold part of the policy. Generally, only the part above the adjusted cost basis is taxed.

The adjusted cost basis is, in plain words, the policy's cost for tax. Among other items, premiums paid add to it, and a yearly amount called the net cost of pure insurance takes it down. A dividend taken in cash also takes it down, so later dividends are more likely to be taxed.

Some of a dividend may go right away to pay a premium or repay a policy loan, under the policy terms. That part is left out. Other options can be taxed in other ways, so ask your accountant about the one you pick.

A simple, made-up example, for illustration

A company's policy has an adjusted cost basis of $8,000. This year, the company takes a $10,000 policy dividend in cash.

$10,000 minus $8,000 is $2,000. Generally, that $2,000 is taxable income for the company. Had the $10,000 gone right away to pay a premium under the policy terms, it would have been left out.

These figures are not from a real client. Your own numbers will be different.

How are the growth and the death benefit taxed?

Growth inside an exempt policy is not taxed each year. An exempt policy is one that passes a test in the Income Tax Regulations. Growth that comes out early is another matter. A cash dividend, policy loan or surrender above the adjusted cost basis is generally taxed.

On each policy anniversary, the test compares the savings in the policy with a limit set by the rules. The yearly tax on policy growth in the Income Tax Act applies to policies that are not exempt.

FCAC says the death benefit is a tax-free payment. Under the Income Tax Act, a death benefit from an exempt policy is not a disposition. When a private company receives it, the amount above the adjusted cost basis generally goes to its capital dividend account. The company files an election to pay a capital dividend from that account. That dividend is generally tax-free to shareholders who live in Canada.

Who does a participating policy not fit?

It is not for everyone. Here are the honest trade-offs:

  • You need coverage for a set time only. FCAC says term insurance covers a fixed period and generally costs less when you first buy it.
  • You want a number you can count on. Dividends, and the growth they bring, are not guaranteed.
  • You may cancel in the first years. Cash values can be zero at first. CLHIA's guideline asks illustrations to show the first year with a cash value.
  • You want an investment. This is insurance, and CLHIA's guideline says illustrations are generally not meant to predict results.
  • You must qualify on health. An insurer can say no.

What can I ask before I decide?

Bring these questions to the meeting, and to your accountant:

  • Which values in this policy are guaranteed, and which depend on dividends?
  • What does the less favourable scenario show?
  • Which dividend option is chosen, and how is it taxed?
  • What is the adjusted cost basis now, and how could it change?
  • In the first years, what cash value is there if the policy is cancelled?

Your accountant leads the tax side. We complement them and share any numbers with them to review. Our life insurance page explains term, whole and universal life. Our post on what to do with retained earnings covers other choices for extra money in a company.

Sources

This information is general in nature and is not tax, legal, accounting, insurance or investment advice. It is based on current Canadian tax legislation, which can change. Any strategy should be designed and reviewed with your accountant and legal advisors based on your circumstances. Tax rates are approximate and reflect current Ontario and federal rules.

Want to see what a policy guarantees before you decide?

A short call walks through the guaranteed and non-guaranteed parts of an illustration, and what to ask your accountant.

Or call us now: 289 339-8100

Thank you! We will call you soon.