Based in Burlington. Helping business owners in Oakville, Milton, Mississauga & Hamilton.

289 339-8100info@lgfinancial.ca

Blog · Critical Illness

Life Insurance With Critical Illness: How the Two Work Together

Life insurance with critical illness cover protects you at two different times. Life insurance pays when you die. Critical illness insurance pays while you are alive, if you are diagnosed with an illness the policy covers.

Couple at home looking at a laptop together
Key points
  • Life insurance pays a one-time lump sum when the insured person dies. In Canada, that payment is generally tax-free.
  • Critical illness insurance pays a lump sum while you are alive, if your diagnosis meets the policy's definition.
  • The CLHIA describes both payments as non-taxable lump sums.
  • You can hold the two as separate policies. Some life policies can also carry critical illness cover as a rider, which is an add-on.
  • In an October 2023 report on universal life sales, Ontario's regulator flagged critical illness riders added to some policies automatically.

Life insurance with critical illness: what does each one pay?

They pay for different events. Life insurance pays at death. Critical illness insurance pays after a diagnosis, while you are still alive.

The Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association (CLHIA) is the group Canadian life and health insurers work through. Its consumer guide compares the two like this:

QuestionLife insuranceCritical illness insurance
When does it pay?When the insured person diesAfter a diagnosis that meets the policy's definition
Who gets the money?The beneficiary named by the policy owner, or the estateYou, or a person you name
How is it paid?One lump sumOne lump sum
Is it taxed?The CLHIA says non-taxableThe CLHIA says non-taxable
Does it depend on work?NoNo. It is not about whether you can work.

A diagnosis alone is not enough for a critical illness claim. The CLHIA says the condition must be covered, and any waiting or survival period must be met. Some conditions must also reach a set level of severity.

A survival period means you must live a set number of days after the diagnosis. It applies to some conditions, and each policy sets the number.

Why would an owner want life and critical illness insurance?

Because they cover different risks. One protects the people and business you leave behind. The other gives you money if you live through a serious illness.

Life insurance can replace income for your family and pay off debts. It can also help keep a business running or buy out a partner. Our life insurance page explains term, whole and universal life.

Critical illness money is not tied to one use. The CLHIA says it can pay for costs other insurance does not cover. Examples are drugs your plan does not pay for, travel for treatment, or time off work for a caregiver.

For an owner, the lump sum can also help the company pay staff and rent while you recover. Our post on what happens to your business if you get sick covers those costs.

Two policies or a critical illness rider: what is the difference?

There are two ways to hold life and critical illness insurance. You can own two separate policies, or add critical illness cover to a life policy as a rider.

Two separate policies. Each one has its own contract, premium and terms. Each pays under its own rules.

A rider. A rider is an add-on to a policy. Some life policies can carry critical illness cover this way. That puts life insurance with critical illness coverage in one contract.

Ontario's Financial Services Regulatory Authority (FSRA) has looked at riders. Its October 2023 report on universal life sales flagged a concern: critical illness riders, with their extra premiums, added to some policies automatically.

A rider is a choice, and it has its own cost. These questions help you see how one works:

  • Does a critical illness claim lower the life insurance amount, or is it paid on top?
  • Which illnesses does the rider cover, and how are they defined?
  • What happens to the rider if the life policy ends or changes?
  • Does the rider end at a set age?
  • How much does the rider add to the premium?

Ask the same questions about a separate policy. Insurers define illnesses in different ways, so the answers can differ from one policy to the next.

Is the money tax-free?

Generally, yes, for the lump sums themselves. The rules change once a company owns the policy and pays money out.

Life insurance paid when you die is generally tax-free. The Financial Consumer Agency of Canada calls it a one-time, tax-free payment. The CLHIA describes the critical illness lump sum as non-taxable too.

When your company owns a life policy, the death benefit generally goes to the company. The part above the policy's adjusted cost basis generally goes into the capital dividend account. That basis is roughly the premiums paid, minus a yearly cost of insurance.

The company can then pay that amount to its owners as a capital dividend, after it files an election. A capital dividend is generally tax-free to a shareholder who lives in Canada.

A critical illness benefit does not go into that account. The account's insurance rule covers only life insurance paid because of a death. So if your company pays a critical illness lump sum out to you, that is generally taxed. Your accountant leads on these points.

How does this fit a company with extra money?

Some owners use money the company already has to pay for both kinds of cover. Each plan starts with a real need for insurance.

  • Life cover: a life policy your company owns is the base of our Corporate Insured Retirement Program. It is insurance first, for owners who need cover for life.
  • Illness cover: with shared ownership, your company owns the illness cover and gets the lump sum. You own a premium refund if you never claim. Our critical illness insurance page shows how it works.

What are the trade-offs?

Having both is not right for everyone. Here are the honest points:

  • Two kinds of cover means two costs. The premiums are a real cost every year.
  • You must qualify on health. An insurer can approve you, leave out a condition, charge more, put off a decision, or say no.
  • Critical illness insurance pays only for illnesses the policy defines. Less severe forms may be left out, or get only a partial payment.
  • A rider depends on its life policy. Ask what happens to it if the life policy ends.
  • You may already have critical illness cover through work or an association. The CLHIA suggests checking that first. Group cover generally ends if you leave.
  • Some owners have enough savings to handle an illness or a death without more insurance.

Sources

This information is general in nature and is not tax, legal, accounting, insurance or investment advice. It is based on current Canadian tax legislation, which can change. Any strategy should be designed and reviewed with your accountant and legal advisors based on your circumstances. Tax rates are approximate and reflect current Ontario and federal rules.

Life cover, illness cover, or both: which fits your company?

A short call covers what each kind of cover would pay, who would own it, and what to ask your accountant.

Or call us now: 289 339-8100

Thank you! We will call you soon.